Thursday, March 18, 2010

Summary Route Comparisons B2H Alternatives

Factors
Western Route
Central Route
Eastern Route
Land Use Characteristics
Length/Counties
275/5
282/6
299/6
Private Land
138 Miles (50%)
172 Miles (61%)
206 Miles (69%)
Public Land
137 Miles (50%)
110 Miles (39%)
93 Miles (31%)
Follows Existing Corridors
46 Miles
58 Miles
111 Miles
New Corridor
229 Miles
224 Miles
188 Miles
Resources
Irrigated Cropland
10 miles
9 miles
22 miles
Forest Clearing
1,754 acres
1,763 acres
681 acres
Rugged Terrain (>25% slopes)
59 miles
56 miles
35 miles
Special Status Streams
46 crossings
13 crossings
8 crossings
Restrictive FS/BLM Visual Classes
9.1 miles
25.5 miles
8.6 miles
Important Issues
John Day Valley
Crosses
Avoids
Avoids
West Side Baker County
Avoids
Crosses
Avoids
Oregon Trail Interpretive Center
Avoids
Avoids
Nearby
National Forests
Malheur and Umatilla (45 miles) New Corridor
Wallowa -Whitman (30 miles) New Corridor
Wallowa-Whitman but in a designated utility corridor (5 miles)
High Construction Difficulty
117.1 miles
99.3 miles
65.3 miles